I only had a problem with one scene: the 'word of god'. You know, where Alannis Morrisette comes out as God, she and Ben Affleck exchange a look, he asks for forgiveness and she screams at him until his head explodes. Except for the part where Alan Rickman wipes his shirt on god's robe, I didn't like it. I thought it lacked subtlety, especially with the fantastic bit where God shows Affleck the error of his ways with just a look; you could feel the torrents of metaphysical parental shame crashing into him. Since I walked out of the theater, I thought it could've been done differently. I wasn't sure how, but my basic idea went something like this comic. I felt that a whisper disposing of Affleck might more effectively show the 'power of God' rather than a scream that sent ripples through the air.
Keep in mind,
1) it is not a storyboard and there were some narrative and artistic corners cut to fit it into a single page.
2) I was going by memory on purpose (rather than hitting You Tube). I double-checked after and think I got pretty close.
3) I really need to practice hands.
Here you go, as always, click to enlarge:

listening to while posting: 'Something to Remember Me By' by Steve Wynn off of Kerosene Man
I’m more of a Chasing Amy kinda guy, that being said…
ReplyDeleteYes, Yes, Yes you nailed it! I think maybe Kevin Smith might have felt he needed a big Hollywood-type ending or something but it rang false due to the budget constraints of the film as well as the direction of the story… A soft moment (less is more) interrupted by Jay’s filthy mouth is actually how this scene should have been scripted and shot. It would have made a great counter scene to the one in Chasing Amy when Silent Bob Talks about Amy and Jay tear into him… Good Job.
thanks, man!
ReplyDeleteI was wondering if it worked. The (now) wife has been listening to my talk about this on and off since we walked out of the theater...
I have to check out Chasing Amy again, too.
He was on Wait Wait Don't Tell Me on NPR two weeks ago and Lo and Behold, he was a funny guy.
This is cool!!!! Great!
ReplyDeleteI like the contrast between the quieter scenes just prior to it and the "What the fuck?" at the end. It's like quiet-loud dynamics in music.
ReplyDeleteThanks very much for taking time to post on my blog. I've posted a response if you are interested.
ReplyDeletehttp://cedrichohnstadt.wordpress.com